Teaching mostly college juniors
and seniors provides me with the opportunity to observe cutting edge early
adopters of new technology. I am mostly
invisible; they regularly walk into me, not looking up from their smartphones
as they walk. I don’t even try this
maneuver.
Sadly,
having to teach/entertain Millennials has a much worst aspect that probably will
bring an end to my full time academic career.
It has reached a point where I am not certain even a 20% core of capable
and conscientious students exist. Only
on a good day can I achieve direct eye contact with this 20% as they at least
temporarily look up from their smartphones.
But what
likely will send me packing is a new deterioration in student-teacher relations
regarding grades. My Gen X and earlier
students accepted a C minus knowing they really did not even deserve this
grade, but were grateful to receive it..
On students’ transcripts a C minus translates into a C and eliminates
the need for re-enrollment.
Millennials
largely believe they should receive something higher despite failing to take
notes, participating in the discussion, or generating test performances above
the already generous C minus.
This semester,
I experienced a remarkably animated and lawyerly bunch when I reviewed the
first test of the semester. The normally
passive and distracted group became quite agitated when their answers did not
conform to mine. Surely their answers were
as good, or better than mine. How could
I know better? What does my 50,000 hours
of experience mean in the first place?
I cannot
express to you the frustration I felt, despite regularly consuming heaping
portions of humble pie as a Professor these days. On student when out of his or
her way to lodge a caustic, unfair and untrue set of allegations on that
special place on the web called Rate My Professor.com. Remarkably that rating appears on the first
page of a Google search using my name. I
found that out when I looked to see whether there was any press coverage of my
Plenary Panel participation at a major global conference in Budapest hosted by
the International Telecommunication Union. No ITU World Telecom Forum coverage,
but Rate My Professor. Com has a new insight of how mean, loud, rude and unfair
I am.
For the
record I cannot yell thanks to vocal cord surgery. Of course I do have a lawyer tone which to
some may come across as yelling. The
test mean was 72 and I goose scores a few points with a generous curve. It may tell you something that the test range
ran from a high of 94 to a low of 30.
If you
think college teaching and an academic career is a cake walk, think again.
1 comment:
Sorry to hear about your surgery. Due to a bad cycling crash, I've been on sick leave since late September. Completely concur with the gist of your post; I prohibit all electronic devices in my classes and I'm not alone. But the ability to take notes is seemingly lost; a course comes down to the study guide and then an exam that accredits rather than evaluates a student's mastery of the concepts and material. But the scariest is the inability of students even to recognize analytical thinking. Teaching in an information society is no picnic!
Post a Comment