Award Winning Blog

Showing posts with label Data Centers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Data Centers. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

Data Centers Can Profitably Clean Up Their Act

 Until a quick and powerful pushback, stealth mode has worked quite well for data center developers to acquire the necessary parcels of land and government approvals.  The prospect of a lasting boost to a long-neglected region was perceived as so irresistible that developers need not worry about building trust, fully disclosing plans, and the time it would take to secure maximum concessions.

Using the playbook perfected by the variety of ventures needing a large geographical footprint, data center developers have quietly acquired the entire patchwork of separately owned properties without having to disclose their future use. Property owners considered themselves quite lucky that someone was willing to buy land in their remote locale. They gladly executed the mandatory non-disclosure agreements without a clue about the intended purpose for their land.

Stealth-mode land acquisition foreclosed the predictable increase in price and potential for local opposition.  At the same time, developers began the process of convincing government officials that data centers would boost the local economy, increase employment, and augment tax revenues. What’s not to like, even though the developers insisted on secrecy?

While first generation data centers occupied large buildings in the central business district of major cities, widely available broadband fiber optic cable capacity has made it possible to construct massively larger facilities anywhere.  The telecommunications carriers operating these transmission facilities gladly agreed to install a link to reach the new data center. The carriers got more traffic revenues, and the data center operator and occupants profited from having an increased capacity to perform the information processing and storage needed to make the Internet work. 

Until the recent pushback, data center developers now could find sites where the landowners and permitting authorities were desperate for new investment and most willing to offer large financial inducements.  Massively large “hyperscale” data centers initially received a hearty welcome by government officials who previously had to tolerate the occasional toxicity and citizen opposition to, hazardous landfills, jails, garbage dumps, fracking injection wells, and, most recently, temporary incarceration facilities to house immigrants lacking proper documentation for residency.

Stealth and maximum extraction of financial concessions accrued ample cost savings, but eventually residents became better apprised of the mixed consequences in data center construction and operation.  Unlike taxpayer underwriting of stadiums, enterprise zones, and costly infrastructure, data center construction and operation typically fail to achieve all the much-touted long term financial benefits, such as large employment numbers after initial construction.  Data center tenants often send expert staff for short term, onsite tasks, because they want to maintain control of proprietary technology and the local pool of prospective employees probably lack necessary training.

The offsetting costs and harms have become common knowledge.  Local opposition has migrated from specific “not in my back yard,” to “not on this planet.” Orbiting data centers eventually may offer a cost competitive alternative, but not until investors, insurers, and other stakeholders are convinced.  Until then, terrestrial data center developers must accept this increasingly obvious problem: without active, conscientious, and costly mitigation of problems, time delays in securing all permits and properties will cost more. 

Simply put, data center operators and their tenants must address concerns about pollution, noise, negative impact on adjacent property values, higher residential electric and water rates, and the likelihood that the ample financial concessions they secured might not fully match future tax and local economy enhancement. Unlike a sports stadium or world class airport, data centers offer little boost to civic pride.

Charm trumps stealth.

    

Wednesday, July 8, 2026

Can Orbiting Data Centers Solve Terrestrial Deal Breakers?

Large data centers provide information processing, storage, and interconnection needed to satisfy ever increasing demand for cloud computing and artificial intelligence. These facilities use massive amounts of electric power, water, and real estate measured in gigawatts, millions of gallons, and millions of square feet respectively.

 Not long ago, data center ventures sought and received generous financial inducements to locate in mostly rural locales in great need of investment. Data centers seemed an attractive alternative to prisons, hazardous material dump sites, and temporary housing for illegal aliens.

The Court of Public Opinion on data centers has quickly pivoted from disinterest, or support to “not in my backyard,” and even “not on my planet you bastards.”   Concerns about data centers include environmental harm, real or perceived upward pressure on retail electricity, water, and residential housing prices, and likely market domination of AI markets by a few “Big Tech” incumbents. Other irritants include noise pollution, and uncertainty whether data centers support the local economy after the initial construction phase.   

Shifting data centers from earth to space has become an alternative touted as solving concerns without generating new ones.  In sun synchronous, low Earth orbit, orbiting data centers (“ODCs”) may have comparatively less environmental impact and lower operating costs in two increasingly expensive categories: the gigawatts of electricity continuously required to power components, and coolants, such as water and glycol, needed to syphon away heat generated by constant operation.

Space Commerce Exuberance

The global consulting firm McKinsey & Company estimates the global space economy will reach $1.8 trillion by 2035, up from their $630 billion estimate for 2023.    Low Earth Orbiting (“LEO”) satellite constellations have the potential to provide reliable infrastructure for widely available and affordable broadband access, even in remote, rural, and impoverished locales throughout the world.   Other developing market opportunities include development of a vibrant space launch and tourism industry, mineral extraction from asteroids, colonization of the Moon and Mars, and an expanded array of services via commercial satellites. 

Some of the world’s most innovative and wealthy entrepreneurs believe space will serve as a profitable frontier well worth the risk and expense.  On the issue of ODCs, Elon Musk made a bold prediction: “I actually think that the cost of deploying AI in space will drop below the cost of terrestrial AI much sooner than most people expect.  . . . I think it may be only two or three years.” 

Replacing terrestrial data centers (“TDCs”) largely depends on declining launch costs and the ability to tap “free” solar energy coupled with efficient radiational cooling of the heat generated from continuous operations. To achieve a comparative advantage over TDCs, ODC satellite constellations must collectively deliver services at or below the per unit cost achieved terrestrially. 

Are ODCs a Viable Extraterrestrial Solution?

ODCs conceptually offer a more environmentally friendly competitive alternative to TDCs.   On the other hand, ODCs will complicate several key space management and governance issues. ODC proponents may have underestimated or refrained from acknowledging significant risks, increased by the massive increase in the number and close proximity of operational LEO satellites.  Potential launches of LEO satellites numbering the millions raise the odds for collisions, especially orbiting in the narrow sun synchronous orbital plane.

Space debris proliferation, without any significant mitigation efforts so far, contributes to congestion, higher collision risks, and the cascading effect of even more debris.  At some point, the potential for calamity reaches a tipping point where investors lose enthusiasm and confidence, particularly when one or more collisions actually occur.

Additionally, the combination of many more spacecraft launches, and deorbiting of decommissioned spacecraft, will generate toxicity and pollution having uncertain impact in space and Earth’s atmosphere.  Consequently, pro-market, regulatory forbearance and statutory interpretations may not continue, particularly if the space commerce environment becomes more risky and costly.

The Gravitational Pull from Unresolved Legal, Regulatory, and Space Governance Issues

The lack of immediate calamities, such as a multi-million dollar collision of two operational satellites, has supported bullish forecasts for space commerce. Yet even with an extraordinary expansion in the size of LEO smallsat constellations, the need to match terrestrial efficiency in information processing and other outputs, or come close, runs up against major technical challenges such as size and weight limitations in launching spacecraft, power production capability of smallsats, and processing power from miniaturized plant. 

It remains uncertain how many small LEO satellites will be needed to match the output available from a current Walmart-sized terrestrial footprint and new hyperscale centers forecasted to have an even larger footprint, with power requirements in the 1-5 Gigawatts range, equivalent to 1-5 nuclear power plants and far more solar, wind, gas, oil, and hydroelectric facilities.

Assuming space as a regulation free, or less regulated venue is highly unlikely. While nation states may appear to lack jurisdiction over spacecraft that quickly moves into and out of airspace, there are terrestrial anchors.  No one questions the legality of national regulatory authorities requiring applications to launch satellites, use radio spectrum, and operate both domestically and internationally.  Additional regulatory authorities can extend to the nation where spacecraft launches occur, gateway and backhaul earth stations operate, and intact space debris causes damage.

Vastly more LEO spacecraft and “paper satellites,” not yet launched, if ever, will test whether nations can effectively coordinate spectrum and orbital plane usage.  As ODC constellations will operate within the narrow parameters of sun synchronicity, they will have to convince regulators, legislators, and investors that potentially millions of satellites, in relatively close proximity, can avoid signal interference, collisions, and orbital coordination conflicts. 

ODC commercial prospects may trend down in the degree of exuberance to cautious optimism based on more realistic assessment of risks and rewards. A sizeable list of challenges includes increased government oversight, coordination and other timetable delays, spacecraft collision potential, whether AI will become profitable, and recognition that operating in space does not eliminate all environmental and other fears, uncertainties, and doubts.